Log in

View Full Version : Canadian Takes on Hollywood in Piracy Case


Zebra 3
May 31st, 2006, 12:17 PM
(CBC) A Richmond, B.C., man has become the target of the Hollywood movie industry in its battles against piracy.

Gary Fung is being sued by the Motion Picture Association of America, which says he is purposely violating film copyrights.

Fung, a 23-year-old computer whiz, operates the website isoHunt (http://isohunt.com).

But Fung says he doesn't steal movies. IsoHunt is a search engine that uses BitTorrent technology so people can find video files that are somewhere on the internet.

His Los Angeles-based lawyer, Ira Rothken, says the studios' case is weak because Fung does not distribute copyrighted files — he simply tells you how to find them.

Fung himself says the studios could make tons of money if they embraced the new technology — but stopping it, he says, is impossible.

"We not going to run, we not going to shut down, and even if they manage to shut us down there's no way to stop the technology and no way for them to stop the internet," he told CBC Television.

The Hollywood studios say millions of people are using the internet to steal films, and that's why they've launched lawsuits around the world against the operators of websites like Fung's.

"There are some people who are not entering into negotiations, not paying licensing fees, don't give a rip about creativity, who are content to steal that product and send it out on the internet," John Malcolm of the Motion Picture Association of America, told CBC.

"That is wrong, that is illegal and that is why we take action."

Fung has 170,000 gigabytes of movies indexed on his website, including hot new properties such as The Da Vinci Code and Mission Impossible III.

"What I see is, basically, the internet taking over phone networks and TV and movies and music, all forms of media," he said.

He estimates seven million people a month use his search engine.

Fung's website backs the demand of the Canadian Music Creators Coalition for an end to lawsuits against music fans and an end to digital locks on music files.

Online piracy is costing Hollywood $2 billion US annually, according to estimates by the Motion Picture Association.

But Fung says the studios should stop fighting technology and join the parade — by selling their movies online, just as music is sold now.

"If they can harness that power to their advantage they can reach a much bigger audience at a much cheaper cost," he said.

But the association is prepared to let the lawsuit wend its way through the court system, while people from around the world turn to Fung's site to find movies.

"Mr. Fung has chosen not to enter into any negotiations with anybody, but rather to steal that creativity and to use it for his own ends in an unlawful manner," Malcolm said.

Dr. Boogie
May 31st, 2006, 01:20 PM
I'm guessing John Malcolm doesn't see any irony in the MPAA saying that Fung doesn't "give a rip about creativity."

Johnny Couth
May 31st, 2006, 09:43 PM
Good luck controlling the flow of data on the internet

"HACK THE PLANET!"

That movie will always haunt me :/

Supafly345
Jun 1st, 2006, 01:23 AM
I love ISO hunt, I've been using it forever.

ArrowX
Jun 1st, 2006, 06:38 PM
I find it hard to accept that theres a 2 billion dollar loss every year from Internet Piracy. I know ALOT of people who use the internet and only one of them "steals" movies. Most of the time anyone else Downloads a movie is one they can't find anywhere.

Emu
Jun 1st, 2006, 06:40 PM
Is there some sort of disorder where people don't realize that the people they know don't constitute an accurate sample of the population?

the_dudefather
Jun 1st, 2006, 07:31 PM
i normaly use torrentspy, but been trying to use other sites mainly because the retarded conspiracy shoutcasts on the torrentspy homepage piss me off

the typical roster will generaly be

"why bush is a big dummy and a poopyhead"
"9/11 - THE TRUTH!!!....acording to random searches on google"
"JFK was killed by a version of himself from the future"
"THEY want to get YOU, but WE know the truth!"

Chojin
Jun 1st, 2006, 09:45 PM
I find it hard to accept that theres a 2 billion dollar loss every year from Internet Piracy.
They get that figure by assuming that the people in question would have paid full retail price for every file downloaded had they not been able to.

ScruU2wice
Jun 1st, 2006, 11:24 PM
Is there some sort of disorder where people don't realize that the people they know don't constitute an accurate sample of the population?

I lold because I imagined you paging through a medical dictionary asking that question aloud to yourself... :(

Emu
Jun 1st, 2006, 11:27 PM
With a monocle on

ScruU2wice
Jun 1st, 2006, 11:28 PM
On a related note, I don't understand arrowx's signature, so I'm assuming that it's low quality pornography that caters to pedophiles. Regardless of what it is, it offends me deeply...

Emu
Jun 1st, 2006, 11:34 PM
It's the scene from Silent Hill where Pyramid Head tears off that girl's skin. If I spoiled it for you I'm sorry but you asked :(

ArrowX
Jun 2nd, 2006, 12:02 AM
yeah the Quality is shit.

Fathom Zero
Jun 2nd, 2006, 01:55 AM
I'm sad, the Pirate Bay was taken down.
But it will be up soon.

I'm getting one of these fuckin' shirts if it's the last thing I do:
http://www.peer99.com/peer99W/swe/shoppen/steg1.asp?hkat=Piratshoppen