The first I ever bought was Weird Al's Off the Deep End, too. :(

My CD collection is insulting to anybody who likes music because I hate music. I have all the Weird Al albums, all the They Might Be Giants albums, and the other 40 are stand-up comedy albums. >:

Oh yeah, I also have the South Park: BLU soundtrack. I should probably throw that away or something. :(

Blues Traveler's Four on tape in 1995. And my first CD was their next album, Straight on Til Morning in 1998.

I went on my own and bought my CD copy of Master Of Puppets when I was 10 so I think I'm comparably more badass than anybody else in this thread. The CD doesn't play anymore :(

Storm Front by Billy Joel. I remember really liking "We Didn't Start the Fire" because I knew all the words to it.

The Eurythmics. I was 8. I still love their stuff from that time to this day.