[ranxer]

i gave the example of the hunter being shot by the dog scene,
do you say that whole scene is based on lies because moore recreated it??

i'd guess that the scene in reality would be more interesting than his recreation(surely he only had a snapshot or the story from the policeman) but it helped the scene stay interesting to recreate it. this practice is done all the time on tv without people yelling "lieing bastards!"

the rest of the critizisms are similar to this please pick one in particular if you don't want to blanket discredit the whole movie for rediculous reasons.. there may be one that i missed that has some meat to really look at.