[pjalne]

I now declare this a full-on spoiler thread.

Yeah, I don't know about the NOOOOOO! thing myself. And I agree with Jin on the cut-in-half thing, most of the time it felt like something happened, and then it was over and didn't resonate through the rest of the movie at all.

And for once, I thought R2 actually was funny. I never really minded the guy, but I've always gone "Yeah, yeah, you're a submarine, that's hilarious, get out of the water so we can see Yoda." And I also loved that after years of fan bitching and speculation about why C3PO doesn't remember anything about Anakin, Lucas just throws in the dude from NYPD Blue going "Oh, and erase their memories while you're at it" to a random guy, and then that subplot is over.