Game: "Grand Theft Auto IV"
System: Xbox 360
Genre: Action
Published by: Take-Two

Reviewer: Dr. Boogie
Posted: 5/13/2008

Review: I was looking forward to the release of GTA IV as much as the next guy, but I have to admit I was skeptical of all the review sites and magazines giving it a perfect score. Thereís been a lot of talk going around that big game review publications have been handing out positive reviews in exchange for advertising dollars and advance copies of games, so youíd think they would try to avoid seeming biased. Now that Iíve played it, however, I can tell you that I understand the temptation to give the game a perfect score.

For starters, Liberty City, Rockstarís nihilistic New York simulacrum, has been re-imagined as being far more similar to its real life counterpart. Even the people who live within the city have been given greater depth than in previous GTA games, bringing home groceries, taking cell phone calls, and even running from the cops. The game is loaded with all manner of small additions too numerous to mention in a single review, and while some may seem superfluous from a gaming perspective, theyíve still arranged in a way not unlike what you would see in a real city.

All that is nice, and it speaks to the dedication of the gameís creators, but more notable are the changes in gameplay from previous installments, particularly San Andreas. Since the entire game takes place in a single city, for instance, there is no opportunity for flying planes, although helicopters remain. Also gone are the RPG aspects of San Andreas, such as improving your ability to handle weapons and vehicles through continued use. This was the one that hit me the hardest, especially with the more realistic driving physics in the game. Plus, this sort of stat-building really lends itself to the 360ís achievement system.

On the other hand, the goal in GTA 4 seems to be giving the player an experience that is more fun, but at the same time more realistic, than previous games. To this end, the game includes one of my personal favorite advances in video game technology: ragdoll physics. Before, a high-speed collision while on a motorcycle would merely toss your character, but now you might hit a car and find yourself cartwheeling down the street before slamming into a building. Even if you hit something while going fast enough in a car, you can expect to go flying through the windshield, accompanied by a scream that never fails to get a chuckle out of me.

One other useful addition to the game is that you can now hail cabs in addition to carjacking them. Once inside, you pick a destination from the list of notable spots (gun stores, safe houses, missions, etc), and then the cabbie drives you there. The real kick, though, is that you can pay a little extra money to basically teleport directly to the spot. Stealing cars can be fun, but at the same time, when given the opportunity to skip long driving sequences before or during a mission, Iíll take it. Suffice to say, by the end of the game, my mileage drive was roughly equal to my mileage ridden in taxis.

Travel aside, combat in the game has been somewhat improved as well. The lock-on system from the previous GTA games remains, but with a gentle pull of the trigger, players can enter a free aim mode to pick off distant and partially covered targets. Even while locked on, players can shift their aim away from the center of the torso to pop bad guys in the head, or just hit them in the shoulder so theyíll convulse their way into the open.

And of course, the more you practice with the aiming system, the sooner youíll get to experience the gameís new wanted level system. The same six-star rating system remains (though without soldiers and tanks lining the streets at 6 stars), only now, the process for losing the heat is better defined. When you do arouse the local constabulary, a circle will appear on the radar centered on your location. To lose the cops, all you need to do is get outside the circle and remain so for a few seconds without being seen by any cops. The trick is that the circle gets much wider with each star, to the point where a six-star rating means that you have to basically escape from one island to another without being seen by anyone. Still, your radar will show all nearby law enforcement officials, and losing the cops at higher levels is possible, even with a chopper on your tail. It just takes some careful maneuvering is all.

The game also tries to improve on the melee system, but this doesnít go over as well. The new hand-to-hand combat system is reminiscent of the one in Saints row, with two punch buttons and a kick for good measure. In lieu of blocking, however, you have a dodge button. In practice, this button means you can avoid a potential attack and come back with a vicious counter, or even disarm your foe. Unfortunately, even the most unremarkable streetwalker seems to have an unusually fast right jab, and when someone has a knife or a bat, I prefer the old disarming method: shoot the bastard. You can work out some combos with punches, but again, so can just about everyone else. Itís a big disappointment, especially given that you could learn several powerful melee styles in San Andreas.

At the same time, though, melee combat is a very small portion of the game, confined almost exclusively to those harrowing missions in the beginning, when guns are in short supply. As such, itís really only a minor problem, along with the occasional flaw with the physics that can prevent Niko from standing back up in a timely fashion after ragdolling onto an incline.

The whole of the game is just excellent. Even the story is a great improvement over the previous titles. Sure, revenge is once again the central theme, but the characters are fleshed out so well in GTA IV that you actually care about them, and you feel bad for them when theyíre subjected to the consequences of a life of crime. I guess what Iím trying to say is that Grand Theft Auto 4 isnít perfect, but itís about as close to perfection as anyone has gotten before.

Overall rating: WholeWholeWholeWholeHalf
(Scored on a 0.5 - 5 pickles rating: 0.5 being the worst and 5 being the best)

Reader Comments

May 13th, 2008, 02:40 PM
I got soured on GTA3 quick and never picked up Vice City or San Andreas because of the bitter taste still in my mouth. However, I've been hearing nothing but good things about this and, now that my stimulus check is in, I may have to pick up a next-gen console to play it.

May 13th, 2008, 04:04 PM
I never really got into the GTA series, although I wonder how this game is doing by now and if it is worthwhile of me getting its attention.
Funky Dynamite
May 13th, 2008, 05:34 PM
Originally Posted by BakaGaijin View Post
I got soured on GTA3 quick and never picked up Vice City or San Andreas because of the bitter taste still in my mouth. However, I've been hearing nothing but good things about this and, now that my stimulus check is in, I may have to pick up a next-gen console to play it.
You may, but it depends on what it was about GTA3 that turned you off.
Forum Virgin
May 13th, 2008, 06:02 PM
Having put about 20 hours into GTA IV and over 100 hours into GTA III, VC, SA combined I can wholeheartedly recommend this game to anyone who enjoyed the previous ones. Still, people who didn't like the games before might not be that impressed by this one either. The improvements made are very gradual.

Anyway, my favourite addition is also the use of "Euphoria" for the ragdoll physics. Stuff like shooting a guy in the leg and watching him stumble and fall, struggling to get back up in a different way depending on the circumstances is extremely satisfying.
Crazed Techno-Biologist
May 13th, 2008, 08:21 PM
well, im not surprised, this is a slim gangster mafioso type fellow instead of GTA's thug life style g's. But i really hated the travel, though i loved the interactive world. what other series lets you get so off track you can hijack a tractor and use it to mow down an entire crew of gangsters as to steal their machineguns?
frappez le cochon rouge
May 13th, 2008, 08:31 PM
Every GTA game has had a different type of protagonist, be it from the last GTA or any other action game. They have consciences, backstories, etc.
Funky Dynamite
May 13th, 2008, 10:18 PM
Yeah, the thug lifestyle was only prominently featured in San Andreas.
Forum Virgin
May 14th, 2008, 04:42 AM
I'm using my "economic stimulus" check to buy a next-gen system and this. Thanks Bush! Your silly plan may not help our economy, but it'll allow me to beat up on virtual hookers.
Retardedly Handsome
May 14th, 2008, 10:07 AM
Thereís been a lot of talk going around that big game review publications have been handing out positive reviews in exchange for advertising dollars and advance copies of games, so youíd think they would try to avoid seeming biased.
This is definitely becoming a huge problem especially for smaller companies. There's really no way around this though. If corporations are shelling out buko bucks for ads in a magazine, you don't want them to pull it. This is why you need to just buy every game and play them yourself. I don't need some jerk off with an english degree and a minor in communications to tell me that the new FIFA 2008 is boring and it hasn't changed over the past 7 years. OF COURSE IT HASN'T ITS SOCCER YOU STUPID FUCK!
Funky Dynamite
May 14th, 2008, 12:00 PM
Believe me, I'd love to be able to do that myself, but my payscale doesn't currently allow for it.
Forum Chaos Lord
May 14th, 2008, 07:32 PM
Icculus, that was awesome and made of win. I owe you a beer.
Fake Shemp
May 15th, 2008, 07:57 PM
Without a doubt, one of - if not the best I've ever played - and I've been playing since Ye Olde Days of Pong. Damn work and responsibilities keep getting in the way of good gaming time - but I've managed (a mere) 43 hours of gaming time since I picked it up on its release date, and I've only got 52% of the game finished - quite impressive since games like Halo 3 and COD4 can be finished in 6-7 hours. The worlds created in GTA (well, from III on anyway) offer a perfect way to escape into another place- IV ups the bar here in ways that are just fantastic - and I'm really looking forward to whatever will eventually come out that makes GTA IV look "outdated". I'm sure it will eventually happen, but for now, and for the next countless hours of roaming the streets of Liberty City I'll be happily glued to the 360 soaking in the eye candy and being amazed at Rockstar's accomplishment.